D2C: Choose Channels and Protect Your Margin

A shopper sees a product in a store, looks it up later, and finds the maker selling the same product on its own website. The two purchases can look similar to the shopper. For the maker, they are different businesses. In one case, a retail partner brings the buyer to a shelf and handles the sale. In the other, the brand must bring the buyer to its site, take the order, answer questions, arrange delivery, and handle a possible return. The second transaction is direct to consumer, or D2C. The question behind the term is whether taking on that work gives the brand enough control and enough contribution from each customer to justify it. Shopify’s guide to D2C describes both the direct sales relationship and the brand’s responsibility for fulfillment and customer experience.

D2C versus SaaS growth: two equal shopping carts holding coins and an open laptop side by side, unmarked price tag, monitor showing abstract chart, closed notebook, potted plant

The useful answer is rarely that every brand should sell only through its own site. D2C is a channel choice, and a company can operate it alongside retail, marketplaces, or wholesale. The first task is to identify which sales are genuinely direct. The second is to compare the value of a direct order with the costs the brand now carries. The third is to decide what each channel should do for the customer and the business. Those decisions make the label useful; putting “D2C” on a presentation does not change who owns the order or pays to win the buyer. Shopify’s comparison of B2C and D2C describes the broader consumer category and the possibility of mixing channels.

The sales relationship, not the screen, defines D2C

D2C means a brand sells to the end customer through a channel it operates. An order on the brand’s own website is the familiar example, but an order in a store operated by that brand can also be direct. In both cases the brand is the seller facing the customer. A brand does not need to manufacture every component, own a warehouse, or build its checkout software to have a direct channel. What matters is the commercial relationship: the customer is buying from the brand rather than from a retailer that bought or lists the brand’s goods. Shopify defines D2C around a brand’s own channels, while its B2C comparison includes brand-operated physical stores.

Business to consumer, or B2C, answers a wider question: is a business selling to an individual consumer? A department store selling a brand’s jacket to a shopper is part of B2C commerce. The jacket maker’s sale through its own site is B2C too, and is also D2C. A sale by the jacket maker to the department store is a business-to-business transaction for the maker, even though the jacket may later reach a consumer. That distinction matters when a report says a brand’s “consumer sales” are growing. The reported amount might describe end-customer purchases at many sellers, or it might describe only the brand’s own receipts. Shopify places D2C within B2C and distinguishes direct sales from wholesale relationships.

Ecommerce is a different axis again. It describes how an order is placed, not whether the brand owns the customer relationship. An order through the brand’s website can be both ecommerce and D2C. A shopper ordering the same brand through a marketplace is using ecommerce, but the brand should not automatically count that as a sale through its own direct channel. A purchase in a brand-operated store can be D2C without being ecommerce. The OECD’s 2025 ecommerce definition focuses on the method of placing the order; payment or delivery may happen offline. A customer who orders on a brand site and pays on pickup therefore does not stop being an ecommerce customer merely because the payment was made at a counter.

The checkout page alone can still mislead. A marketplace listing may carry the brand’s photos, wording, and product name. A social post may send a shopper to a brand site or keep the purchase inside a third-party sales channel. To classify the sale, follow the order: who is the seller to the customer, who sets the terms, who receives the order, and who is responsible when the item is late or wrong? This is a practical way to apply the channel distinction, not a new formal definition. It prevents a brand from treating every online mention, every marketplace order, and every buyer of its product as a customer it can serve directly. The D2C and B2C comparison distinguishes brand-operated channels from retailers and marketplaces.

That distinction has an immediate consequence for customer knowledge. A direct seller can see the orders and interactions that occur in its channel and can respond to the buyer there. A maker selling through a retailer sees what the retailer shares, which may be enough for replenishing stock but less useful for understanding why an individual bought again or returned an item. Direct access is valuable because it can improve product pages, service, and follow-up, but possessing order data is not itself a strategy. The brand still has to decide what question the information answers and what it will change. Shopify’s channel comparison connects direct channels with closer customer relationships and different access to customer information.

The extra revenue from a direct order comes with extra costs

When a brand sells through a retailer, the retailer receives part of the final selling price in exchange for its selling role. Selling directly can leave more of that price with the brand, but the brand must perform or buy the work the retailer used to do. That includes attracting shoppers, processing orders, packaging and shipping products, dealing with returns, and helping customers after purchase. Control over the page and the price is real; so is responsibility for a parcel that misses the delivery promise. Shopify’s D2C guide identifies fulfillment, returns, and customer experience as part of the direct brand’s job. Its channel comparison also notes the added marketing and logistical demands of a direct channel.

Consider a purely illustrative product sold to a shopper for $100. Suppose a retailer buys it from the brand for $60, while the brand spends $30 to make it and $5 to ship it to the retailer. The brand has $25 left from that wholesale order before fixed overhead and other costs. Now suppose the brand sells the same product for $100 on its own site. It spends $30 to make it, $15 on expected delivery and returns, $5 on payment and site costs, and $25 to acquire that first customer. The brand again has $25 left before fixed overhead and other costs. These are assumed figures, not industry averages. The example shows why the larger direct selling price does not by itself prove that D2C is more profitable.

The same illustration also shows why a second purchase can change the answer. If that customer later buys the $100 product directly again and the brand incurs no new acquisition expense, the amount left under the other assumptions rises from $25 to $50. Real repeat orders may still require email, service, a discount, or another marketing expense, so $50 is an upper bound in this simplified example, not a forecast. Conversely, if the first order costs more than $25 to win, or a high share of orders are returned, the direct channel can yield less than the retailer route. The sensible comparison uses actual order economics and the expected pattern of repeat purchases, with each cost assigned to the channel that caused it.

This is why “cutting out the middleman” is an incomplete economic argument. An intermediary can charge for access to shoppers, shelf space, checkout, delivery, or service. Those charges are visible. The brand’s replacement costs may be scattered across advertising, staff time, packaging, software, failed deliveries, refunds, and slow-moving inventory. A decision based only on the difference between the wholesale price and the site price counts the benefit in one place and hides the work in several others. Direct selling is attractive when the brand can perform that work well enough, or learn enough from the relationship, to make the extra responsibility worthwhile. Shopify describes both the control and the additional operating demands of D2C.

Customer acquisition needs a denominator and a time horizon

The direct channel has no retailer shelf to bring every shopper to the product. Customer acquisition cost, or CAC, is a useful starting measure because it divides sales and marketing spend in a period by the number of newly acquired customers in that period. That is the formula Shopify gives for ecommerce acquisition cost. If an illustrative brand spends $12,000 in a month on acquiring customers and wins 300 new customers, its measured CAC for that month is $40 per new customer. Calling the $12,000 “marketing” while counting only ad spend, or counting repeat buyers as new customers, would change the answer. The period and the definition of a new customer belong next to the number.

CAC is not a verdict on a channel by itself. A $40 CAC can be sensible for a product that leaves $60 after product, delivery, payment, and expected return costs on the first order. It is harder to defend if those costs leave only $20 and there is little reason to expect another purchase. The missing fact is the contribution a newly acquired customer produces over the period the brand is willing and able to fund. The brand should avoid treating all later sales as free, but it should also avoid judging a naturally repeatable product solely on the first checkout. This is a decision rule derived from the cost formula and the direct seller’s operating responsibilities, not a claimed industry benchmark.

Repeat-customer rate supplies one piece of the missing picture. It compares customers who have purchased more than once with all customers in the group being measured. Shopify states the repeat-customer-rate formula. If 240 of an illustrative 1,000 customers have each bought at least twice, the rate is 24% for that defined group. A rate without a period is easy to misread: customers who first bought last week have had less time to return than customers who first bought a year ago. The denominator may also change if a team mixes customers from its own store with customers who purchased at a retailer, where individual purchase histories are not available in the same way.

Group direct customers by when they first purchased, then compare what those groups do after the same amount of time. A January group can be examined at three months after first purchase and compared with a later group at its own three-month mark. That approach makes a product or marketing change easier to interpret than comparing two groups with unequal time to buy again. Shopify’s customer cohort report groups customers by first-order period and displays repeat purchases over later intervals. The report does not turn a second purchase into proof of satisfaction; it provides a clearer view of the behavior the brand needs to explain.

The kind of product changes what a fair time horizon looks like. A replenishable product might give a useful read on repeat behavior relatively soon. A durable product may be successful even when few buyers need a second unit quickly. For that product, the brand should look at whether the first order supports the acquisition cost, and whether customers buy accessories, replacements, or other items only if those possibilities are part of the actual offer. The same repeat-rate target should not be imposed on both products. Before increasing paid traffic, a direct seller should know the time it can wait to recover acquisition cost and whether the observed cohorts are old enough to support that expectation.

Recurring subscriptions require different revenue measures

Some direct brands offer subscriptions, and a subscription changes the reading of repeat purchases. A customer agreeing to a recurring order has a different arrangement from a customer deciding afresh each month whether to buy. A subscription can make future demand more visible, but the brand still needs to deliver the promised product and handle changes or cancellations. Shopify’s D2C guide includes subscriptions as one variation of the model. The revenue measures used for a recurring service can help explain the arrangement, provided the business does not quietly treat ordinary one-time orders as contracted recurring revenue.

Monthly recurring revenue, or MRR, describes recurring revenue on a monthly basis; annual recurring revenue, or ARR, expresses the recurring base over a year. One-time payments are outside those measures. Stripe’s explanation of MRR and ARR discusses them for businesses with repeatable, predictable charges. A direct seller with both subscriptions and individual orders should show those streams separately. Calling every sale to a previous customer “MRR” would confuse repeated purchasing with an active recurring commitment. Likewise, multiplying a strong sales month by twelve does not make all of that month’s one-time orders ARR.

Net revenue retention, or NRR, asks a narrower question about the recurring revenue from customers present at the start of a period. It includes expansion and contraction among that existing group and excludes revenue from newly acquired customers. Stripe’s NRR explanation gives that cohort-based structure. For an illustrative monthly subscription business that starts with $10,000 of recurring revenue, loses $1,000 from cancellations and $500 from downgrades, and gains $2,000 from upgrades by those starting customers, ending revenue from that group is $10,500. NRR is 105%: $10,500 divided by the original $10,000. Another $3,000 from brand-new subscribers may increase total MRR, but it does not enter that NRR calculation.

The boundary matters because the three measures answer different questions. MRR or ARR describes the size of a recurring base. NRR describes how that starting base changes without credit for new customers. Repeat-customer rate describes how many buyers have made more than one purchase in a defined commerce population. A direct physical-goods seller might need the repeat and cohort measures while a recurring service needs the recurring-revenue measures; a business with both needs both views, with clear populations. A high NRR cannot establish that a one-time product has strong repeat purchasing, and a high repeat-customer rate does not establish a stable subscription base. The definitions come from Shopify’s repeat-customer guide, Shopify’s cohort report, and Stripe’s recurring-revenue guidance.

A mixed channel strategy needs a job for each channel

Direct selling does not require abandoning retailers or marketplaces. A brand can use its own site or store to explain a product fully and serve customers who seek it out, while partners put the product in front of shoppers who would not have visited the brand. Shopify describes D2C alongside retail, marketplaces, and wholesale. The choice is practical: which channel can reach this customer, explain this product, and deliver it at a contribution the brand can accept? If a retailer provides discovery or in-person access the brand cannot reproduce economically, the retailer’s share of the sale may be payment for a valuable service.

The complication is that channels can compete for the same order. If the brand sells an identical item at a substantially lower public price on its own site, a retail partner may have a harder time selling the stock it already bought. If the brand instead makes its site the only place to obtain every popular item, a retail partner may have too little reason to stock the range. A coherent approach starts with the customer’s reason to use each channel. The brand site may offer fuller product information, a wider range, or a direct service relationship; the retailer may offer convenient discovery and immediate pickup. These are possible channel roles, not guaranteed benefits. Shopify’s D2C guide discusses the tension between a direct channel and retail partners.

Product assortment and promotion need the same clarity. A direct-only bundle can create a reason to visit the brand’s site without silently discounting the identical retail item. A broad promotion across the same item may be worth coordinating with partners if those partners carry substantial stock. The brand should know whether a new product is meant to start on its own site for customer feedback, launch at retail for reach, or appear in both places. Otherwise, channel mix becomes an accident of where the last customer happened to click. Shopify’s comparison notes that companies can combine direct and partner channels and must consider their different roles.

Shared inventory makes these choices more concrete. A sale on the brand’s site and an order from a retailer can draw on the same units, but the promises are different. The direct customer sees a delivery estimate and a return policy; the retail partner expects an agreed quantity to arrive. If the brand promotes stock it has already committed elsewhere, the direct channel has bought a customer relationship by breaking an order promise. Before adding more traffic, the brand should know which units are available to each route and who handles a return from each. This follows from the direct seller’s fulfillment responsibility described in Shopify’s D2C guide.

Channel reporting should preserve these distinctions. A brand’s direct-site orders, brand-store orders, wholesale invoices, and consumer purchases through partners are different events and may have different prices. Adding them together without stating whose revenue is counted can make a channel look larger than it is. The better view pairs each channel’s sales with its own selling costs and service obligations. When customers move between channels, the business can still learn from the pattern, but it should not credit the direct site for a retailer’s transaction merely because the buyer first read a brand article. Shopify’s B2C and D2C comparison supplies the underlying separation between direct and intermediary sales.

Build the direct offer around a reason to buy there

A direct channel begins with a real customer reason to choose it. “Buy from us instead” is weak if the shopper can get the same item faster, with easier returns, at a familiar retailer. The brand can make a stronger case by answering product questions clearly, offering the full range, making a suitable bundle available, or providing service that helps the customer choose and use the product. Which reason matters depends on the item. A product that is hard to understand may need better explanation; a product that is easy to understand but inconvenient to replace may need dependable replenishment. The brand should select one reason it can actually deliver and make the product page, checkout, and follow-up serve that reason.

That promise must survive the first order. The customer needs to know what is being bought, when it should arrive, what it will cost to receive, and what happens if it is unsuitable. If the brand promises a particular delivery experience, it needs stock, packing, shipping, support, and returns arrangements that can support the promise. A polished site cannot compensate for a late parcel or an unclear refund. Shopify’s D2C guide identifies fulfillment and returns as part of the brand’s direct responsibility. The brand can use outside service providers for some tasks, but the customer will still look to the seller for a resolution.

Only then does a traffic plan become meaningful. Paid advertising, referrals, search, email, and a retail partner’s awareness can all lead a person toward a direct purchase, but the brand should be clear about which activity is acquiring a new customer and which is serving an existing one. The CAC calculation needs sales and marketing spend and the new-customer count for the same period. Shopify’s acquisition guide provides that formula. If a campaign brings many low-value first orders but the resulting customers rarely return, a low cost per click offers little comfort. If an offer produces fewer first orders but each leaves enough contribution to recover acquisition cost, it may be the stronger route.

The first customers are also a source of specific questions. Which product detail did they need before ordering? Did a delivery promise match what happened? Why did an item come back? Did a buyer need help using it? Direct selling gives the brand a chance to connect those questions with the order and improve the page, offer, or service. That opportunity is a reason to start with a manageable offer and a working support process. More orders amplify both a good experience and a defect in the experience. Shopify’s D2C guide ties the model to direct customer contact and responsibility for the experience.

Choose direct, partner, or both according to the work they do

A direct channel should lead when the brand can give the shopper a worthwhile reason to buy there, fulfill the order reliably, and recover the cost of finding that shopper within a tolerable time. A product needing explanation or a continuing relationship can make that case especially compelling, provided real customers respond as hoped. The price the brand retains is only one part of the decision. If order contribution remains thin after acquisition, delivery, returns, and service, a bigger direct share of sales may make the business more fragile rather than stronger.

A partner should lead when that partner supplies reach, convenience, or an in-person buying experience the brand cannot reproduce at an acceptable cost. The brand gives up some control and some of the final selling price in return for that work. A hybrid approach is sensible when the channels solve different customer problems and the company can keep pricing, stock, and service promises coherent across them. Shopify’s B2C and D2C comparison describes direct and partner sales as channels a company can combine. “Hybrid” is not a compromise by default; it is a choice that earns its place when both routes have a clear job.

The deciding facts are often local and ordinary: the brand’s actual acquisition cost, the contribution left by a delivered order, the share of orders returned, how long a new customer takes to buy again, and what a retailer contributes that the brand cannot provide itself. A company missing those facts should start by separating its channel results and watching first-purchase cohorts before making a sweeping claim about the best model. A customer asking “What is D2C?” needs the short definition: the brand sells to the end customer through its own channel. A business deciding whether to do more of it needs the longer answer: direct selling is worth pursuing when owning the relationship improves the customer’s experience and the economics after the brand pays for the work that relationship requires.

One person. A whole marketing team.

Invite only